Best Pizza in Alachua

We believe that best authentic Italian recipes use only the freshest ingredients

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Greek Salad

Fresh spinach, hearts of romaine lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, black and kalamata olives, topped with feta cheese & pepperoncini.

Gluten Free Crust Pizza (10")

Gluten free crust cheese pizza with pizza sauce.

Chicken Wings (10)

Homemade Meat Lasagna

2 layers of meat sauce, ricotta, topped with mozzarella cheese.

Italian Meatball Stromboli

Mozzarella, sliced meatballs and marinara sauce.

Gyro

Toasted pita bread with your choice of beef and lamb combination or chicken, served with tzatziki sauce, cucumbers, onions, lettuce, tomatoes, and a side of fries.

Introducing Our Amazing New Pasta!

Introducing Our Amazing New Pasta!

Imported from Sicily, our Busiate pasta is not only delicious, but healthier too! Customize your favorite dish of ours or purchase the pasta uncooked to prepare from home!
Learn more

Check out our Lunch Buffet

Check out our Lunch Buffet
Every day from 11:00AM to 3:00 we serve the best lunch buffet in Alachua County. Hot pasta dishes, delicious pizza, and a massive salad bar with fresh fruit and homemade cream puffs and much more for you to enjoy!

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Our family loves New York Pizza Plus. They are always great with service and quality of ingredients for their food. Definitely a must eat at restaurant in Alachua

Anna A.

Anna A.

New York Pizza Plus has been one of my longtime favorite. Good food, good service, and good prices. They definitely deserve the 5 stars I'm giving them.

Mark C.

Mark C.

We drive 45 minutes to have lunch here at least once a week because of the quality, the variety and presentation of the food. Even on the buffet, is great

Kacey R.

Kacey R.

Featuring

Gluten-Free Options

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Vegan Options

Only Fresh Ingredients

Only Fresh Ingredients
We invest in quality ingredients to ensure our customers get the great taste we’re famous for. Because we believe that you deserve the best.

Made With Love

Made With Love
Our secret ingredient is passion. Everyone on our team is passionate about making your time with us as great as it can be – from start to finish.
New York Pizza Plus Rewards

New York Pizza Plus Rewards

Become a VIP, win $500

Authentic Italian Fare

Authentic Italian Fare
At NY Pizza Plus, we believe that best authentic Italian recipes using only the freshest ingredients. Our meals hand-prepared with fresh pastas and the freshest regional ingredients.

Frequently asked questions

We serve the following areas: Alachua, High Springs, Alachua County.

Our location